Private vs public sector pay: who really gets more?

The general consensus is that public sector pay is lower than in the private sector, but staff have better working conditions and job security. The reality is very different, says Merryn Somerset Webb.

I wrote earlier about the gold plated pensions our MPs and MSPs have and the way in which those pensions (and the regularly rising salaries that lead up to them) might prevent our leaders from really grasping the financial stress they are putting the rest of us under. 

But it isn’t just the public sector workers at the top of the tree that might be finding it hard to grasp just how tough it is in the private sector at the moment: the truth is that, across the board, public sector workers do better than private sector workers. 

In an article in the Sunday Times last week Dominic Lawson pointed to an ONS publication I missed when it came out – Public and Private Sector Earnings in the UK: 2019. This contains, says Lawson (and I agree), a “statistical marvel: the first time that the ONS has... arrived at a single number... to express the overall average differential in remuneration and benefits between the private and public sectors.” 

This “raw premium” was 7%. Yes you read that right. In 2019 if you had worked in the public sector you would have been on average 7% better off than if you had worked in the private sector. 

That premium was higher for lower-skilled workers than for higher: employees in lower-skilled occupations earned on average £13.62 an hour in the public sector and only £11.24 in the private sector. This goes against the accepted wisdom in the UK. 

Most people reckon that, if it is money you want, to go to the private sector. If it is job security and the warm feeling of general service you want, you go to the public sector – where lower salaries are compensated for by said security and service stuff. 

But if the public sector offers more money (largely thanks to the whopping pension entitlements almost everyone gets – 82% of public-sector employees get a defined-benefit pension) as well as more job security, where does that leave us? In a tricky situation. 

There’s been much talk about how the Covid crisis has exacerbated inequalities across the board in the UK; there has been little about how the main inequity in the UK is between the public and private sectors. Most public sector workers have no idea that this dynamic exists. Given the huge stresses on the public finances (financed by the private sector…) it would surely be better if they did.

Recommended

Is London’s office market a bargain?
Property

Is London’s office market a bargain?

Private-equity groups are swooping on London’s property companies, which are trading on steep discounts to net asset value.
23 Oct 2020
Big spending government is here to stay – just ask Rishi Sunak
UK Economy

Big spending government is here to stay – just ask Rishi Sunak

Governments around the world are splashing huge amounts of cash as they do “whatever it takes” to prop up their economies. John Stepek looks at where …
23 Oct 2020
Why negative interest rates are a lousy idea
UK Economy

Why negative interest rates are a lousy idea

The Bank of England’s governor says negative interest rates can encourage investment rather than having cash stashed in the bank. But is that really t…
22 Oct 2020
I wish I knew what negative interest rates were, but I’m too embarrassed to ask
Too embarrassed to ask

I wish I knew what negative interest rates were, but I’m too embarrassed to ask

There’s been a lot of talk from the Bank of England recently about introducing “negative interest rates”. So what on earth are they, and what would th…
20 Oct 2020

Most Popular

Negative interest rates and the end of free bank accounts
Bank accounts

Negative interest rates and the end of free bank accounts

Negative interest rates are likely to mean the introduction of fees for current accounts and other banking products. But that might make the UK bankin…
19 Oct 2020
Why commodities could be the best investment for 2021
Commodities

Why commodities could be the best investment for 2021

There’s plenty for investors to worry about right now. But things will inevitably recover. And the sector most likely to do best when they do, says Jo…
22 Oct 2020
UK post-Covid recovery stocks: these 20 companies could be set to rocket
Share tips

UK post-Covid recovery stocks: these 20 companies could be set to rocket

Finding stocks with the potential to rise tenfold or even further is far easier said than done. But the pandemic has produced the most promising backd…
22 Oct 2020